July 21, 2020

Kyle Kulinski vs Sam Harris on Israel

Filed under: Uncategorized — admin @ 12:49 pm

I was going through Sam Harris interviews lately, and stumbled upon this video by Kyle Kulinski. Sam Harris, and to a lesser extent David Pakman, are pro-Israel while many on the Progressive left are very critical of it. Now, you can definitely see people’s various biases and tendencies in the following clip, such as Sam Harris’ equating Hamas with ISIS, etc. but I found Kyle Kulinski’s objection to be the most off-base, and I need to call it out. Normally I find Kyle to always argue in good faith, intellectually honest, scrupulous about giving examples and careful to say reasonable things. But not here. And that speaks to the defensibility of the position itself:

Sam Harris: “What if the roles had been reversed, and they had all the power?”

Wait what? So Kyle’s argument is that – Sam Harris may be right about a massacre of Jews occurring if you switched positioned today – but if you roll it back to 1947, with Arabs having superior firepower things would have ended up roughly the same but reversed.

Really Kyle, if positions were switched in 1947 then there would not be a massacre? If anything there would have been an even bigger massacre, if the combined Arab armies actually won back then!

In fact, we don’t need to guess. For starters, let’s look at the actual Arab leaders at the time. Let’s look at what Al Husseyni, the grand mufti of Jerusalem said over and over before 1947. He went and met with Hitler and then helped the Nazis:

Adolf Hitler talking to Grand Mufti Haj Amin el Husseini

In his radio broadcasts, Ai Husseini is reported to have said things like “Arabs, arise as one man and fight for your sacred rights. Kill Jews wherever you find them. This pleases God, history, and religion. This saves your honor. God is with you.” This is the same man who Egypt later placed at the head of the first “All-Palestine government” in Gaza, their first attempt to create a Palestinian state.

Before 1947, we can look at the actions of Arabs in Mandatory Palestine, and their revolts against Jewish immigration, and massacres against unarmed Jews, but one can argue that these would not have escalated into a full-scale assault on Jews in the Yichud at the time. Instead, for that, we can look at leaders of Arab states outside the area.

Look at what the Secretary-General of the Arab League openly warned in 1947 about Arabs everywhere: that the establishment of a Jewish state in the region would lead to “a war of extermination and momentous massacre which will be spoken of like the Mongolian massacre and the Crusades.”

Kyle, what are you talking about? I guess to be charitable to your point, we can see what was actually done with Jews by TransJordan, a much more benign state, run by Hashemites who had a secret peace agreement with Israel. After capturing Jerusalem, they renamed themselves to trans-Jordan, gave all Palestinian Arabs citizenship (good) and then expelled the Jews from Jerusalem. An Arab commander remarked, “for the first time in 1000 years, not a single Jew remains in the Jewish Quarter [of Jerusalem]“.

Jordan continued to raze synagogues and turned them into chicken coups, vandalized the Jewish cemeteries on the mount of olives, and Islamicized the whole region.

Okay, so it was “only” ethnic cleansing, so they didn’t kill Jews like the Farhud in Iraq, or the official policies in Iraq, or like the anti-Jewish riots in Egypt in 1945 or bombings in Cairo, or the other 900,000 Jews who had to run for their life from Arab countries where they lived for hundreds of years. Here is a more extensive list of Jewish expulsions, including from Arab countries, so thinking it won’t happen “this time” or some other time should be taken with a tablespoon of salt.

Kyle, why don’t you ask Siri “how many Jews live in {Syria | Iraq | Libya | etc. }? Seriously, go ahead and ask. Now why is the world silent about all those refugees? Because they were resettled in many countries, including Israel and they and all their children have citizenship. The same should have happened to Palestinian refugees. We should have the same today, for native-born Lebanese who are denied citizenship because they have a Palestinian grandfather, and are therefore kept stateless to this day. In the past, I have written about regional solutions to end this shameful situation.

So no, you don’t have to guess what would happen if the Jews had been defenseless vs various Arabs. You saw it happen all throughout the middle east after 1947. Whether due to Pan Arabism, or Islamic supremacy, or other reasons, they were pissed that Jews had formed their own state. The fact that Israel continues to exist today as a state is because they were able to defend themselves against all those seeking to destroy them — not just their state but actually intending to commit genocide.

So, as Sam Harris says, “intentions matter”. But, just because one side is vastly more powerful, does that mean they can’t do better? Yes, they can and they should. They should push back against war hawks and supremacists in their own government. Kyle put out a far better video a year prior, included below, explaining why intentions aren’t the only thing that matters.

But, I agree with Sam Harris on this: if you are intellectually honest, you have to admit the facts I laid out above. Attempting to say “well, maybe a genocide wouldn’t have happened” is not enough – what group of people would lay down their arms and take such a foolish risk? Here is what was said after the war by the leaders of the new Jewish state:

We must start working in Jaffa. Jaffa must employ Arab workers. And there is a question of their wages. I believe that they should receive the same wage as a Jewish worker. An Arab has also the right to be elected president of the state, should he be elected by all. If in America a Jew or a black cannot become president of the state—I do not believe in the quality of its civil rights. Indeed, despite the democracy there, I know that there are plots that are not sold to Jews, and the law tolerates this; and a person can sell his plot to a dealer on condition that it not be bought by a Jew … Should we have such a regime—then we would have missed the purpose of the Jewish State. And I would add that we would have denied the most precious thing in Jewish tradition. But war is war. We did not start the war. They made the war. Jaffa waged war on us, Haifa waged war on us, Bet She’an waged war on us. And I do not want them again to make war. That would be not just but foolish. This would be a “foolish hasid.” Do we have to bring back the enemy, so that he again fights us in Bet She’an? No! You made war [and] you lost.27


  1. What’s the last date I can post this to to arrive in time for Christmas? vulvodynia flare ups on elavil The opposition Democratic Party had filed a criminal complaint against Matsushima, accusing her of violating the election law by distributing paper fans to voters.

    Comment by Nigel — October 20, 2020 @ 8:04 pm

  2. I do accept as true with all the ideas you have presented for your post. They’re very convincing and can definitely work. Nonetheless, the posts are very brief for starters. May just you please extend them a little from subsequent time? Thank you for the post. dhcp servern svarar inte

    Comment by — October 20, 2020 @ 8:14 pm

  3. I’d like to pay this in, please fluticasone propionate nasal spray over the counter The irony is not lost on English bowlers like James Anderson and Stuart Broad — two fine examples of aggressive swing bowling — who have been beaten at their own game of using the art of swing on the green-lively pitches they grew up on

    Comment by Sherman — October 20, 2020 @ 8:26 pm

  4. Lost credit card diarex The majority of funding — $130 million — will go to the National Institutes of Health (NIH), which is tasked with developing a voluntary national research cohort of 1 million or more Americans who are willing to share their genetic data with researchers.

    Comment by Brice — October 20, 2020 @ 8:48 pm

  5. Would you like to leave a message? tadalista 20mg In early awards, Richard Linklater’s “Boyhood,” filmed over 12 years, has emerged as the front runner

    Comment by Delmer — October 20, 2020 @ 9:10 pm

  6. Спасибо за совет
    секреты болгарки

    Comment by Aaronsax — October 20, 2020 @ 9:27 pm

  7. Will I get paid for overtime? is it ok to take diflucan when pregnant German Chancellor Angela Merkel, Italian Prime Minister Matteo Renzi and Cameron were among 44 foreign leaders marching with Hollande on Sunday

    Comment by Terence — October 20, 2020 @ 9:31 pm

  8. We’d like to invite you for an interview is griseofulvin microsize over the counter The American Kennel Club has recognized four more dog breeds, including a Spanish fishing dog and a South African guard dog, in a move allowing them to compete in prestigious canine competitions nationwide.

    Comment by Emory — October 20, 2020 @ 9:53 pm

  9. A Second Class stamp metoprolol and fluid retention As the two square off, Kobayashi, using his famous “Solomon method” in which he cuts the wieners in half, appears no match for the tiny animal

    Comment by Billy — October 20, 2020 @ 10:15 pm

  10. History inexpensive bimatoprost The usual political dynamic: mayors set the agenda in the first year of their term, as they cash in the political chits that won them the office while the governor and everyone else in Albany runs for reelection

    Comment by Isaias — October 20, 2020 @ 10:37 pm

  11. Have you got a telephone directory? metoprolol er succinate 25mg and alcohol The group previously fought against the extremist Islamic State group, which now holds a swath of territory across Syria and Iraq

    Comment by Destiny — October 20, 2020 @ 10:59 pm

  12. Всем привет


    Comment by Lelandweins — October 20, 2020 @ 11:03 pm

  13. I can’t get through at the moment detrol 4 mg coupon code KineMed’s test has a patient drink a small amount of waterwith the non-radioactive hydrogen molecule, deuterium, whichaccumulates in new collagen, the main component of fibroticscarring

    Comment by Darell — October 20, 2020 @ 11:21 pm

  14. I’m doing a phd in chemistry levitra side effects alcohol “Many mothers are unnecessarily anxious or impatient if there's too much reliance on the expected date of delivery,” Gardosi says

    Comment by Darron — October 20, 2020 @ 11:42 pm

  15. Thanks for calling benzac w bestellen “Sequestering 1.1 million metric tons of carbon dioxide each year is the equivalent of eliminating carbon emissions from 232,000 cars.”

    Comment by Quinn — October 21, 2020 @ 12:04 am

  16. I wanted to live abroad sulfasalazine buy online uk He made two starts at the end of the regular season and we’re to believe, despite the way he looked, especially throwing the splitters he threw, that he is cured

    Comment by Ivory — October 21, 2020 @ 12:47 am

  17. Another service? buy isoptin sr The 2015 Chevy NASCAR racecar inside the trailer is valued at $250,000, according to a police report

    Comment by Sandy — October 21, 2020 @ 1:08 am

  18. I’d like to open an account zyvox side effect hyponatremia Since the conflict began, more than 220,000 people have been killed and 1 million wounded

    Comment by Dylan — October 21, 2020 @ 1:30 am

  19. I absolutely love your site.. Excellent colors & theme. Did you develop this website yourself? Please reply back as I’m planning to create my own site and would like to find out where you got this from or what the theme is named. Many thanks! top model sverige

    Comment by — October 25, 2020 @ 10:35 pm

  20. This is very interesting, You are a very skilled blogger. I ave joined your rss feed and look forward to seeking more of your excellent post. Also, I have shared your website in my social networks!

    Comment by builders in Halifax — October 26, 2020 @ 3:07 pm

  21. Normally I don at read post on blogs, but I would like to say that this write-up very compelled me to try and do it! Your writing style has been surprised me. Thanks, quite nice article.

    Comment by stiiizy pink acai — October 26, 2020 @ 4:50 pm

  22. Hi it’s me, I am also visiting this web page regularly, this web page is truly nice and the visitors are really sharing good thoughts. hemnet trelleborg bostadsrГ¤tt

    Comment by — October 26, 2020 @ 7:20 pm

  23. I believe everything published was actually very reasonable. But, consider this, suppose you wrote a catchier title? I am not saying your content is not good, but what if you added a headline that grabbed a person’s attention? I mean is kinda boring. You should look at Yahoo’s front page and see how they write post titles to get viewers to click. You might add a video or a related picture or two to grab people excited about everything’ve got to say. In my opinion, it could make your posts a little livelier. vad Г¤r koloskopi

    Comment by — October 26, 2020 @ 11:57 pm

  24. Wow, great post.Really looking forward to read more. Will read on

    Comment by ����� ����� — October 27, 2020 @ 7:22 am

  25. It’s an remarkable paragraph designed for all the online users; they will get advantage from it I am sure. mikael kors espadrillos

    Comment by — October 27, 2020 @ 12:33 pm

  26. Thank you for another informative blog. The place else may just I get that kind of info written in such an ideal method? I’ve a mission that I’m simply now operating on, and I’ve been at the glance out for such info.

    Comment by — October 27, 2020 @ 1:23 pm

  27. It’s actually a great and helpful piece of information. I am satisfied that you just shared this useful information with us. Please stay us informed like this. Thank you for sharing. fГ¶rslag text tackkort

    Comment by — October 27, 2020 @ 7:16 pm

  28. Every weekend i used to pay a quick visit this web site, as i want enjoyment, as this this web page conations actually good funny information too. lexington strandväska rea

    Comment by — October 27, 2020 @ 11:24 pm

  29. I in addition to my guys were actually following the best secrets from your website and instantly I got a terrible suspicion I had not thanked the website owner for those strategies. Those young boys happened to be absolutely joyful to study all of them and already have sincerely been tapping into these things. Appreciation for genuinely very helpful and then for making a decision on certain useful information millions of individuals are really desirous to learn about. My sincere apologies for not expressing gratitude to you earlier.

    Comment by kd 13 — October 27, 2020 @ 11:24 pm

  30. Needed to send you one bit of remark in order to say thanks once again just for the magnificent techniques you’ve shared above. It was really wonderfully generous with people like you to make unreservedly just what a number of us could possibly have supplied as an electronic book to make some dough on their own, and in particular since you might well have done it if you ever decided. These pointers also served as a good way to realize that other people online have similar dreams just like my own to see more on the topic of this problem. I think there are many more pleasant instances up front for individuals that take a look at your blog post.

    Comment by supreme hoodie — October 27, 2020 @ 11:25 pm

  31. I am glad for writing to make you understand what a helpful experience my cousin’s child went through reading your web page. She figured out lots of issues, which included how it is like to possess an awesome giving character to make other people without difficulty know just exactly specified tricky issues. You actually exceeded our desires. Thanks for showing those useful, trustworthy, educational not to mention fun tips about that topic to Kate.

    Comment by supreme clothing — October 27, 2020 @ 11:25 pm

  32. What’s up, of course this article is really nice and I have learned lot of things from it on the topic of blogging. thanks. potatis pГҐ olika sГ¤tt

    Comment by — October 28, 2020 @ 9:23 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment